Bridging global disparities in geriatric functional assessment: From Western-centric tools to culturally adapted scales in rural African settings — a systematic narrative review
Ibrahim Npochinto Moumeni, France Mourey
Full text PDF 
( Download count: 26)
AbstractBackground: Geriatric functional assessment remains anchored in tools developed in Western, urban contexts, creating substantial measurement disparities when applied to older adults in low-resource African settings where activities, environment, and cultural frameworks differ fundamentally.
Research Aim/Question(s): This systematic narrative review examines the extent and consequences of these disparities, synthesises evidence for culturally-adapted approaches, and evaluates the development and validation of the Functional Assessment Scale for Elderly in Rural Africa (EFAMRA-UdS) as a contextually appropriate alternative.
Methods: A systematic narrative review of peer-reviewed literature was conducted across PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, and Africa-Wide Information (January 2000 – December 2024). After screening 847 records, 50 sources were retained based on predefined inclusion/exclusion criteria and quality appraisal using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT).
Results: Standard scales (Katz ADL, Lawton IADL, Barthel Index) demonstrate systematic validity limitations in rural African populations: infrastructure dependencies, conceptual non-equivalence, and literacy requirements. The EFAMRA-UdS achieved 96% acceptability, inter-rater reliability κ = 0.82, and 18-minute administration time in preliminary validation (n = 30). EFAMRA-UdS detected functional deficits missed by conventional tools in 34% of cases.
Conclusion(s): The available evidence suggests that a transition from universal Western tools toward culturally adapted, community-validated instruments represents a promising and potentially feasible direction for more equitable geriatric care in low-resource African settings. Healthcare systems, academic institutions, and international organisations would benefit from prioritising the development, validation, and implementation of context-specific assessment tools as both a moral and scientific imperative.Keywords: functional assessment; geriatrics; health disparities; cultural adaptation; rural health; EFAMRA-UdS; gerontechnology; assistive technology
Ibrahim Npochinto Moumeni, France Mourey (2026). Bridging global disparities in geriatric functional assessment: From Western-centric tools to culturally adapted scales in rural African settings — a systematic narrative review. Gerontechnology, 25(3), 1-11
https://doi.org/10.30289/gt.202604_25(3).1242